Guest blog by uxpertise

Rolling out online proctoring inside a Learning Management System (LMS) can feel daunting—for administrators and learners alike. Concerns around usability, learner stress, and an increase in customer support requests often slow adoption.

The reality is that when online proctoring is implemented thoughtfully, it can be seamless, learner-friendly, and highly effective—while actually reducing operational complexity.

Based on uxpertise’s experience supporting regulators and credentialing bodies, here’s what it truly takes to successfully roll out online proctoring inside an LMS, while ensuring reliable results and a positive learner experience.

{{download-resource-cta}}

1. Choose an LMS With Proctoring Already Integrated

One of the most important decisions happens before rollout even begins.

Whenever possible, organizations should choose an LMS with online proctoring already integrated, rather than relying on disconnected third-party tools. An integrated approach:

• Simplifies onboarding for administrators and learners
• Enables faster deployment of proctored exams
• Reduces technical friction and user confusion
• Minimizes IT and support dependencies

When proctoring is built directly into the LMS, learners stay in a single, familiar environment—no juggling platforms, no unnecessary steps.

2. Pilot Before Scaling

Before launching to your full learner population, run a pilot test with internal staff or a small group of learners.

A pilot helps you:

• Validate exam workflows end-to-end
• Identify usability or communication gaps
• Confirm rules and technical requirements
• Gather real user feedback

This step alone can prevent a large volume of avoidable support requests and ensures a smoother full-scale rollout.

3. Prepare Learners With Clear, Simple Resources

Learner preparation is one of the biggest drivers of success.

We recommend creating:

• A short video tutorial explaining the proctoring experience
• A simple written guide outlining key steps
• A practice proctored exam so learners can test the process in advance

Practice exams are especially effective. They reduce anxiety, build confidence, and ensure learners know exactly what to expect—long before exam day.

4. Clearly Communicate Exam Rules and Requirements

Transparency builds trust and compliance.

Make sure learners understand:

• Identification requirements (for example, government-issued ID)
• What is not permitted (phones, notes, additional devices)
• The need for a quiet, private testing environment
• Technical requirements such as camera, microphone, and internet connection

Clear expectations upfront significantly reduce issues during the exam and lower post-exam support inquiries.

5. Let Learners Know What Happens After the Exam

Many learners are uncertain about what happens once an exam is submitted.

Communicate clearly:

• How exams are reviewed
• When results will be available
• Whether any additional verification may occur
• How to get help if they have questions

This clarity reinforces confidence in the integrity of the process and reduces unnecessary follow-up requests.

6. Prioritize User Friendliness and Reliable Results

Successful online proctoring should support learners—not intimidate them.

A well-integrated solution:

• Is intuitive and easy to use
• Requires minimal technical knowledge
• Produces reliable, defensible outcomes
• Strengthens trust in assessment integrity

When learners feel supported, adoption increases and confidence in the system grows.

{{post-stat-highlight}}

Case Study: CMRAO’s 80% Reduction in Support Requests After Switching Proctoring Technology

CMRAO, a uxpertise client, had been delivering online exams using a different proctoring solution within the uxpertise LMS. While functional, the experience created friction for learners and resulted in a high volume of customer support requests.

When uxpertise made the decision to switch technology providers and integrate Integrity Advocate directly into the LMS, the impact was immediate.

After the transition, CMRAO experienced:

• An 80% reduction in customer support requests
• A noticeably easier experience for learners
• No required software downloads
• A more intuitive, user-friendly interface
• A truly seamless, all-in-one assessment environment

By combining an integrated proctoring solution with clear learner preparation and guidance, CMRAO significantly improved both learner experience and operational efficiency.

A Successful Rollout Is About Preparation, Not Complexity

Rolling out online proctoring inside an LMS doesn’t need to be complex or disruptive.

By choosing an integrated solution, piloting before launch, preparing learners proactively, and focusing on usability, organizations can:

• Reduce support requests
• Improve learner confidence
• Maintain high standards of integrity
• Scale assessments with confidence

At uxpertise, we believe the most effective proctoring solutions are the ones learners trust—because everything simply works.

Access our webinar on-demand

Ahead of the Curve: Building Trustworthy Licensing Programs in a Changing Assessment Security Landscape
Why modern regulators and credentialing bodies need integrated systems, not disconnected tools, to stay credible, compliant, and confident.

On-demand webinar

Protecting your licensing program
in the age of AI.

Watch our joint session with uxpertise and CMRAO to see how leading credentialing bodies are securing exam integrity without sacrificing the candidate experience.

Human review on every flag No install required 98% client retention Zero breaches in 12 years

Recognized on G2

Watch On Demand Free to watch. No registration required.
Ready when you are.

The National Payroll Institute issues two professional designations, the Payroll Compliance Professional and the Payroll Leadership Professional, held today by more than 21,000 members. Integrity is one of NPI's four core values, so when the COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid shift away from honor-based, supervisor-led proctoring, NPI needed an online solution that could uphold that standard at scale.

Key Outcomes

• 57% reduction in academic integrity incidents, from an average of 86 per month down to 37
• Fewer than 1% of users require technical support
• More than 30,000 exams proctored with a seamless experience

Challenge

NPI's first attempt at online proctoring didn't hold up. The system required plugin downloads, ran on a limited set of browsers, and offered no French-language support for the 12% of NPI's membership that operates in French. Close to half of students hit a technical issue during their exam. For a body responsible for validating the competency of more than 17,000 PCP and 4,000 PLP designation holders, that wasn't a minor inconvenience. It was a threat to the credibility of the credential itself.

{{post-block-quote}}

A Complete Transformation in User Experience

After switching to Integrity Advocate, the technical support burden that used to consume staff time became close to invisible. Integration with NPI's D2L Brightspace LMS meant students could move directly from coursework into a proctored exam without separate logins or downloads, and the entire implementation took a single 45-minute setup meeting, compared to weeks of troubleshooting under the previous system.

"We're getting very little feedback," Pacella said. "And that's amazing. That speaks volumes. That's exactly what we want. You don't hear about software that works well typically... But if it didn't work, you better believe we're going to hear about it a lot."

Dramatic Improvement in Academic Integrity

Paired with a proactive integrity education module, NPI's average dropped from 86 incidents per month to 37, a reduction of more than half, and the improvement held steady over time.

"We went from an average of 86 incidents per month, and it dropped more than in half, down to 37," Pacella said. "And that's been very consistent since we implemented some of these resources and things for people to understand what academic integrity means."

The reduction wasn't just about fewer incidents. It was about quality. The incidents that remained were genuine violations, not technical false positives or misunderstandings about proctoring protocols. That let NPI's review committees spend their time on legitimate concerns instead of sorting through noise, producing more consistent, more defensible decisions.

Seamless Student Experience

Daniela Kwiatkowski, NPI's Manager of Learning and Professional Development, experienced the system firsthand when she took one of NPI's own courses. Her experience highlighted how the technology disappeared into the background, letting students focus on demonstrating their professional competency.

"Before you do it for the first time, you're thinking, how am I going to do this?" Kwiatkowski said. "I moved the camera to one corner and then I forgot about it, and it was easy to forget about it. It wasn't constantly there... now I could focus on the exam, which is what we want people to do."

Scaling Success Across the Organization

NPI's growth didn't stop once the technical problems were solved. According to Steven Van Alstine, Vice President of Professional Standards and Education, NPI moved from proctoring a few thousand students to e-proctoring every student pursuing the Payroll Compliance Professional designation, a ramp-up that happened in under three months.

"We were able to scale that up dramatically through our move to D2L Brightspace and the integration with Integrity Advocate," Van Alstine said. "There was a point at which we maybe had a few thousand students being e-proctored, to the point now where every one of our students is e-proctored... and that ramp-up happened in less than three months."

That rapid scaling extended across NPI's mixed delivery model, including partnerships with public and private academic institutions alongside direct-to-student programs, without requiring different standards across channels.

Administrative Efficiency and Confidence

Decision-making that previously took weeks now happens within 48 hours, with clear evidence and streamlined processes. The administrative team developed communication templates and tracking systems to ensure consistent, fair handling of every incident.

"Giving someone a zero on an exam or failing a course is a big deal," Kwiatkowski said. "I cannot emphasize it enough... Having the peace of mind to know this is an incident that was flagged for the right reasons... we are very confident that this is legitimate."

Advice for Other Organizations

NPI's guidance to other certifying bodies is straightforward: technical due diligence up front saves significant time later.

"There are a lot of products out there," Pacella said. "And you're going to reach out to them, and the sales team will talk a big game about all the wonderful things they can do. Take your time and understand the technical aspects of implementation before making a decision."

{{post-cta}}

When safety training can mean the difference between life and death, there's no room for shortcuts. For over 60 years, Alliance Safety Council (ASC) has set the standard for high-risk workforce training, ensuring every program is legally defensible and fully compliant.

Key Outcomes

• Reduced travel and costs, as participants can now complete training from anywhere
• Improved access and scalability with a mobile-friendly system for on-site or remote training
• Maintained legal integrity through identity verification and participation monitoring
• Lower environmental impact from fewer miles traveled

Challenge

ASC serves high-risk industries like petrochemical, power generation, and manufacturing, where compliance isn't optional. To maintain legally defensible training records, ASC historically relied on in-person, proctored training. Every participant underwent identity verification and close monitoring, allowing ASC to serve as an impartial third-party administrator for its clients.

{{post-block-quote}}

Moving online risked losing the third-party oversight ASC relied on for compliance and legal defensibility. High travel costs and time off work created unnecessary barriers for workers, and most proctoring solutions on the market required software installations, failed security protocols, or introduced IT headaches for enterprise clients.

ASC needed a scalable, secure online proctoring solution that could match the integrity of their in-person process without adding complexity for learners. Beyond technology, they needed a partner who understood their challenges and could adapt alongside them.

"We didn't want to just be a customer of a software solution," Kohls emphasized. "We needed someone who had the level of patience and interest to come along on this road with us."

Results

With Integrity Advocate as a proctoring partner, Alliance Safety Council has redefined how high-risk workforce training is delivered, expanding access while maintaining the highest compliance standards. With mobile-friendly proctoring, legally defensible verification, and a trusted partner by their side, ASC has eliminated travel barriers, reducing time off work and operational costs as well as carbon footprint for participants. Workers can now complete training on-site or remotely, even during outages and unplanned events, while identity verification and participation monitoring keep training records legally defensible.

"We've never felt alone on this journey," Kohls said. "Integrity Advocate's expertise and commitment have been with us every step of the way."

A Partnership Built on Trust

Proper training protects lives, prevents accidents, and ensures workers in high-risk industries are fully prepared for their jobs. That's why finding the right partner matters: safety training isn't just about meeting requirements, it's about trusting that every worker has the skills they need to stay safe on the job.

"They've gone above and beyond to help us educate our customers," Kohls said. "There's no other vendor that would fly from Canada to South Louisiana to host a lunch-and-learn for 30 people. That's because we're more than just a customer to them, and they're more than just a vendor to us."

As workforce training evolves, Alliance Safety Council and Integrity Advocate continue to set the standard, ensuring safety programs meet the highest benchmarks for reliability, compliance, and real-world impact.

{{post-cta}}